Do CHF patients improve aerobic capacity primarily through heart rate?
Answer
No they do not. Here is the bottom line. Because the central function, meaning the heart itself or the central mechanism. Because of rate limitations. Because of contraction limitations. The improvement in someone with CHF does not come through changes in central mechanism because we cannot count on that. It comes through a second mechanism. Oxygen uptake is a function of stroke volume times heart rate times the AVO2 difference. If my heart is shot, forgive me for that rather dramatic term, but if it is not going to be rehabable - it is not once the scar is formed - what mechanism homeostatically do I have to improve a patient's function? Why not just say to them, "I am sorry, you have 3 to 5 years. You are just going to have to get your affairs in order." How can we and why should we work with these patients? Because it has been shown that when the central mechanism of the heart cannot function, the periphery's ability to extract oxygen picks up and helps make up for the deficit of the heart itself. I had a physician one time say to me, "this patient is here to die. They have an ejection fraction of 17. Just make them comfortable." I said, "you keep them stable. I will get them stronger." This patient was on a transplant list. We got into a rehab program, and that patient was taken off the transplant list because we progressively exercised him. We could not change the scarred heart. The damage had been done, but the periphery, the muscles, improved their extraction of oxygen. That patient enjoyed an enhanced quality of life again due to the training that had improved oxygen extraction in the periphery. That is our whole rationale for working with these patients. That is a great question and provides the rationale for what it is that we do. You may be backed against a wall one day being asked why are you working with that patient if their heart is bad? Their periphery is not bad. We can still make a difference that way.
Donald K. Shaw, PT, PhD, D.Min., FAACVPR
Donald K. Shaw is a Professor of Physical Therapy at Midwestern University. Prior to his present position, Dr. Shaw was an Associate Professor of Physical Therapy at Texas State University where he was Director of the Telehealth Program. In 1997 he joined the physical therapy faculty at East Carolina University serving as an Associate Professor in the Physical Therapy Department until 2002. He has also served as Director of Cardiac Rehabilitation at Saint Thomas Hospital in Nashville, Tennessee and as Adjunct Assistant Professor at Vanderbilt University. Dr. Shaw is a Fellow and former national board member of the American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation. He has lectured and presented research in Argentina, Scotland, Ireland, Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, the Peoples Republic of China, and throughout the United States. His published work appears widely in medical journals including the Journal of Cardiopulmonary Rehabilitation, Respiratory Care, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, Cardiopulmonary Physical Therapy Journal, Heart and Lung, Journal of Allied Health, and the American Journal of Cardiology.
Related Courses
1https://www.physicaltherapy.com/pt-ceus/course/neuro-examination-back-to-basics-3862Neuro Examination: Back to BasicsThis course will provide participants with a practical guide through the comprehensive neurological physical therapy examination. The course will progress from the neurological screen through all the specific areas of examination common in persons with neurological diagnoses. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyPhysicalTherapy.comwww.physicaltherapy.comNeuro Examination: Back to BasicsThis course will provide participants with a practical guide through the comprehensive neurological physical therapy examination. The course will progress from the neurological screen through all the specific areas of examination common in persons with neurological diagnoses. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.3862OnlinePT120M
This course will provide participants with a practical guide through the comprehensive neurological physical therapy examination. The course will progress from the neurological screen through all the specific areas of examination common in persons with neurological diagnoses. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.
2https://www.physicaltherapy.com/pt-ceus/course/pharmacology-for-heart-failure-and-5175Pharmacology for Heart Failure and COPD: Implications for Physical TherapyHeart failure (HF) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are two chronic conditions for which medications and physical therapy are important parts of treatment. Thus, therapists across the healthcare continuum need to appreciate the indications, mechanism of action, side effects, and implications for physical therapy for the various medication classes for HF and COPD.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyPhysicalTherapy.comwww.physicaltherapy.comPharmacology for Heart Failure and COPD: Implications for Physical TherapyHeart failure (HF) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are two chronic conditions for which medications and physical therapy are important parts of treatment. Thus, therapists across the healthcare continuum need to appreciate the indications, mechanism of action, side effects, and implications for physical therapy for the various medication classes for HF and COPD.5175OnlinePT120M
Heart failure (HF) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are two chronic conditions for which medications and physical therapy are important parts of treatment. Thus, therapists across the healthcare continuum need to appreciate the indications, mechanism of action, side effects, and implications for physical therapy for the various medication classes for HF and COPD.
3https://www.physicaltherapy.com/pt-ceus/course/caregiving-for-spinal-cord-injury-4921Caregiving For The Spinal Cord Injury PatientThis course will explore how to identify caregiver challenges, as well as resources and creative problem-solving solutions available for caregivers and patients with spinal cord injuries. Case studies will be discussed at the end of the course to engage providers to think critically and ask questions to advance our treatment plans.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyPhysicalTherapy.comwww.physicaltherapy.comCaregiving For The Spinal Cord Injury PatientThis course will explore how to identify caregiver challenges, as well as resources and creative problem-solving solutions available for caregivers and patients with spinal cord injuries. Case studies will be discussed at the end of the course to engage providers to think critically and ask questions to advance our treatment plans.4921OnlinePT60M
This course will explore how to identify caregiver challenges, as well as resources and creative problem-solving solutions available for caregivers and patients with spinal cord injuries. Case studies will be discussed at the end of the course to engage providers to think critically and ask questions to advance our treatment plans.
4https://www.physicaltherapy.com/pt-ceus/course/using-bed-as-progressive-resistive-4946Using the Bed as a Progressive Resistive Exercise Environment: An OT and PT PrimerA patient who spends a lot of time in their bed can now be challenged with bed-based exercises and activities that are as challenging as in the gym. PT and OT providers will learn 20+ novel ways to use the bed as a progressive resistive exercise tool.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyPhysicalTherapy.comwww.physicaltherapy.comUsing the Bed as a Progressive Resistive Exercise Environment: An OT and PT PrimerA patient who spends a lot of time in their bed can now be challenged with bed-based exercises and activities that are as challenging as in the gym. PT and OT providers will learn 20+ novel ways to use the bed as a progressive resistive exercise tool.4946OnlinePT120M
A patient who spends a lot of time in their bed can now be challenged with bed-based exercises and activities that are as challenging as in the gym. PT and OT providers will learn 20+ novel ways to use the bed as a progressive resistive exercise tool.
5https://www.physicaltherapy.com/pt-ceus/course/diabetes-in-adults-current-guidelines-3958Diabetes in Adults: Current Guidelines and EvidenceThis course gives us an overview of diabetes in adults, discusses current perspectives and guidelines, and addresses its significance in PT practice. It also looks at some of the current literature that addresses the evidence for risk factors and interventions and to see how they may apply to our practices. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyPhysicalTherapy.comwww.physicaltherapy.comDiabetes in Adults: Current Guidelines and EvidenceThis course gives us an overview of diabetes in adults, discusses current perspectives and guidelines, and addresses its significance in PT practice. It also looks at some of the current literature that addresses the evidence for risk factors and interventions and to see how they may apply to our practices. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.3958OnlinePT120M
This course gives us an overview of diabetes in adults, discusses current perspectives and guidelines, and addresses its significance in PT practice. It also looks at some of the current literature that addresses the evidence for risk factors and interventions and to see how they may apply to our practices. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.
