PhysicalTherapy.com Phone: 866-782-6258


Can Flawed Research Articles Get Published?

Stephen C. Allison, PT, PhD

August 15, 2012

Share:

Question

Do research articles that are flawed get published?

Answer

For about 10 or 11 years, I have been on the editorial board of the Journal of Orthopedic and Sports Physical Therapy.  I have reviewed for multiple other journals as well.    

The sad truth is, yes. You may ask, how can that happen?  Don't these journals have quality controls? Aren't there reviewers with a string of initials behind their name who are paid to review these things and make sure no fatally flawed evidence shows up in our journals?

You have to realize that this is a human effort.  As a reviewer, you are actually not paid. We do this as a labor of love. Most reviewers for journals are academicians and some are clinicians. Essentially, all are asked to review on a pro bono basis. We are reviewing these manuscripts in the evenings and on weekends. It is an imperfect process.  I think that all of the people engaged are full of integrity in doing their best.  But, there are definitely articles that slip through the net and get published with serious validity threats - some serious flaws.  We all have to have the skills to perform critical appraisal ourselves.  


stephen c allison

Stephen C. Allison, PT, PhD

Stephen C. Allison is a physical therapist engaged in teaching, research, and consultation. He holds degrees from Brigham Young University (BS), Baylor University (MPT), the U.S. Army War College (MSS), and The University of Texas at Austin (PhD). He was a faculty member and Director of the U.S. Army-Baylor University Graduate Program in Physical Therapy at Fort Sam Houston, Texas from 1994 - 2001. He has numerous publications in peer-reviewed journals and serves as an Associate Editor for the Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy. Dr. Allison currently holds faculty appointments at Baylor University and Rocky Mountain University of Health Professions, where he holds the Evidence in Motion Chair in Evidence-Based Practice. Dr. Allison is also working for the US Army Research Institute for Environmental Medicine to develop computational and statistical models to predict injury and physical performance deficits in military training. He is a nationally known speaker and an expert on the integration of research evidence in clinical practice.


Related Courses

Breaking Down Research for the Physical Therapist Assistant
Presented by Kevin Cezat, PT, DPT, GCS
Recorded Webinar

Presenter

Kevin Cezat, PT, DPT, GCS
Course: #4665Level: Introductory2 Hours
  'Glad this was approached and offered for PTA's'   Read Reviews
This course will review the common terminology and definitions used within research and the role of research literature within physical therapy practice. We will review example techniques for breaking down the quality of research and ways to implement research within therapy practice.

Understanding Data and Statistics for the Physical Therapist
Presented by Kevin Cezat, PT, DPT, GCS
Recorded Webinar

Presenter

Kevin Cezat, PT, DPT, GCS
Course: #4708Level: Intermediate2 Hours
  'I now feel able to understand if a particular study is effective in statistically predicting a particular outcome'   Read Reviews
This course will review definitions and guidelines on data and statistical tools commonly used within research and their application to physical therapy programming. We will review example research article breakdowns and the knowledge translation process to identify how to accurately manipulate, interpret, and implement data and statistics into your physical therapy practice.

Improving Your Professional Writing: Tips to Assignment and Publishing Success
Presented by Teresa Fair-Field, OTD, OTR/L
Recorded Webinar

Presenter

Teresa Fair-Field, OTD, OTR/L
Course: #3988Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'The breakdown of the presentation components was extremely helpful '   Read Reviews
This course aims to elevate your writing skills and improve the ability to communicate in academic, professional and research environments. Learners will examine tricky writing conventions, citations, writing organization, and professional voice, along with the chart writing habits we need to un-learn to communicate outside of our profession! This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT/PTA.

Supporting the LGBTQ Senior in Healthcare
Presented by Kathleen D. Weissberg, OTD, OTR/L, CMDCP, CDP, CFPS
Recorded Webinar

Presenter

Kathleen D. Weissberg, OTD, OTR/L, CMDCP, CDP, CFPS
Course: #4096Level: Intermediate2 Hours
  'The instructor was clear and experienced and had interesting anecdotes to share/illustrate the concepts'   Read Reviews
This training describes the required elements for responding to the emerging needs of long term care communities to provide sensitive and respectful services to LGBT elders. The training reviews definitions related to sexual orientation and gender identity challenges experienced by LGBT older adults, and strategies for communication and policies that honor residents' rights. This course is directly related to the practice of physical therapy and is therefore appropriate for the PT and PTA.

OASIS E: New Items
Presented by Cindy Krafft, PT, MS, HCS-O
Recorded Webinar

Presenter

Cindy Krafft, PT, MS, HCS-O
Course: #4612Level: Intermediate2 Hours
  'Good information, a lot of details to cover in a short period of time'   Read Reviews
The course will focus on the items that are unique to the OASIS E data collection process. Official guidance sources will be explored to ensure the accuracy of the information.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.